How to Make Better Decisions Under Pressure

Listen below.

We all face moments when life feels chaotic: when the stress mounts, time is short, and the stakes are high. Whether you’re navigating a personal crisis or managing survival scenarios like a power outage, poor weather, or economic instability, your ability to make calm, clear decisions determines the outcome far more than the situation itself.

As a former trauma ICU nurse, I know firsthand what it’s like to make decisions with lives hanging in the balance, under pressure, with limited information, and no room for panic.

The good news? You can train your decision-making muscle.

Let’s explore how to make better decisions using proven psychological tools adapted for both everyday choices and emergency preparedness. Then I’ll introduce you to a grounded, practical decision-making framework you can use anytime, anywhere.

---

Why We Make Bad Decisions (and How to Prevent Them)

These two checklists have been successfully adapted for high-pressure decision-making:

---

IM SAFE Checklist (Personal Readiness for Decision-Making)

Before acting, check your state:

• I – Illness: Are you feeling unwell, sick, or off?
• M – Medication: Are you under the influence of anything that affects clarity?
• S – Stress: Are you overwhelmed, anxious, or emotionally reactive?
• A – Alcohol: Have you consumed alcohol that may impair judgment?
• F – Fatigue: Are you tired or running on empty?
• E – Eating/Emotion: Are you hungry, hypoglycemic, or emotionally charged?

Example: After a long day of prepping your pantry and managing finances, you notice you’re snapping at family members and struggling to focus. Two or more items on IM SAFE are checked. That’s your cue to rest, not decide.

In aviation, two checked boxes mean the flight is grounded. In your life? That’s your cue to pause.

---

PAVE Checklist (Environmental and External Pressures)

This framework reminds us to consider:

• P – Personal Readiness: Already addressed through IM SAFE.
• A – Assets or Tools: Do you have the right equipment, health, or skills for the task?
• V – Variables (Environment): Are you ignoring weather, time, or environmental conditions?
• E – External Pressures: Are you feeling rushed, people-pleasing, or acting from guilt?

Example: You’re deciding whether to drive into town during a storm. The roads are icy (V), you’re low on sleep (P), and your spouse nudges you to go anyway (E). Use PAVE to say “Not now.”

In both survival and personal life, ignoring the pressure you’re under leads to poor decisions. Your resilience grows when you acknowledge and step back from external urgency.

---

Use This Free Checklist to Build Your Calm Decision-Making Habit

Before we dive into the STEADY Framework, take a moment to anchor this learning:

Download your free printable checklist featuring the IM SAFE and STEADY decision-making tools.
It’s designed to help you:

• Recognize when you’re too compromised to make a smart choice
• Follow a calm, repeatable process under pressure
• Feel grounded whether you’re making grocery lists or bug-out plans

👉 Click here to get your Steady Decision-Making Checklist
(Perfect for your fridge, emergency binder, or go bag.)

---

The STEADY Framework: A Calm, Grounded Approach to Decision-Making

To move from reactive to responsive, use this tool in everyday and emergency situations:

• S – Scan (Check, assess, observe): What’s happening inside and around me?
• T – Triage (Prioritize, sort, urgent vs later): What needs action now? What can wait?
• E – Evaluate (Think, weigh, compare): What are the risks? What are the most grounded choices?
• A – Act (Decide, do, execute): Take calm, confident action aligned with your values.
• D – Debrief (Reflect, review, learn): What worked? What will I do differently next time?
• Y – Yield (Flex, adapt, shift): Can I shift if new information arises?

Example: You’re choosing between stocking up on shelf-stable food or investing in home repairs. Using STEADY, you scan finances and safety, triage needs, and decide to repair first, stock second.

This decision framework works beautifully whether you’re deciding how to handle a disagreement or how to navigate a survival challenge like food rationing or bugging out.

---

Reflection Prompt

When was the last time you made a rushed decision that you later regretted?
How would the IM SAFE or STEADY framework have helped?

Jot it down. Awareness is the first tool in your kit.

---

Everyday Preparedness Meets Practical Survival Skills

When integrated with mental resilience strategies like those found in survival psychology and preparedness training, this calm framework enhances your:

• Emergency decision-making (bug-out plans, shelter choices, food prep)
• Financial decisions (budgeting, resource management)
• Home preparedness (family planning, risk assessment)
• Everyday stress management (relationships, career, parenting)

🧭 Explore further: Read more on survival mindset and situational awareness (coming soon) or browse our mindful prepping basics.

---

Final Thought: Grounded Decisions Create Safer Futures

The more you practice calm decision-making when conditions are stable, the more reliable it becomes when things are not.

Start now. Print your Steady Decision-Making Checklist, featuring the IM SAFE and STEADY frameworks. This one-page printable includes the IM SAFE and STEADY frameworks to help you stay grounded in stress, chaos, or emergency.

Tape it to your fridge. Add it to your go bag. Use it at the kitchen table. Tape it inside your journal as a trusted tool to help you lead with clarity, calm, and capability, no matter what comes your way. The more you practice, the steadier you become.

Because in the end, it’s not just about surviving; it’s about making grounded, wise choices that lead to lasting resilience.

References & Inspiration:
This post was inspired by insights from Dr. Alice Boyes’ article, How to Prevent Bad Decisions, originally published on Psychology Today.